--Boundary_(ID_nJhiGiEo6HG9SyiJ7iOh9g)
X-Orig-Content-type: multipart/alternative;
boundary="Boundary_(ID_bbhStso929xHWSkuxeFeqA)"
--Boundary_(ID_bbhStso929xHWSkuxeFeqA)
X-Orig-Content-type: Text/Plain; charset=iso-8859-1
X-Orig-Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT
The "Bat Iso" my drawing refers to is the same device I use with my slide in
camper on my truck. It allows me to charge both batteries from the
alternator. It's also supposed to isolate the batteries such that loads on
the camper battery won't drain the truck battery and vice versa. My
intention was to run a large battery with the capability to start the engine
and a small motorcycle battery just to power the ignition if something goes
wrong with the main battery/alternator. Although, the odds that the
alternator and the main battery fails at the same time should be low. Of
course, the alternator could stop charging the battery and then the battery
gets drawn down from driving all the loads. I'd have to have a pretty poor
engine instrument scan to not notice. I am planning on an ampmeter and
voltmeter. A low voltage light would be nice too.
The "Bat Selector" in the drawing refers to exactly that. A switch to
select one battery or the other for use. I have one on my boat. It's a
huge thing that would have to go on the side panel down by my lower leg or
something. Wish it could be smaller but I guess it has to be large due to
the cables and current capacity.
I set my dual electronic ignition up exactly as specified by MSD for use in
circle track racers. There is no mention in MSD documentation of being able
to run both ignitions at the same time. I'd have to call them and ask if
that can be done.
I don't know what an "RG" battery is or what "ANL" stands for.
I do have a current limiter between the batter and the alternator: a 60 amp
circuit breaker. I did overlook overvoltage though.
I agree that there's no technical need for an avionics master. I just like
to set my radio volume and squelchs up once and then I don't have to do it
again. I just turn the avionics master on. I can also get clearances
without spinning up my gyros.
Too late on fuse blocks versus CBs. The CBs are all installed in a two inch
channel that runs along the bottom of the main panel. Turned out pretty
nice actually. I also used circuit breakers that can all be pulled. So I
have a bunch of switches to power stuff off individually if I want. I heard
a story about a guy whose turn coordinator started smoking and he had to run
with the entire electrical off just due to one device. Don't know if it's a
true story, but it's a good story.
Thanks for your advice and to the others that responded.
Mike Kimball
P.S. I've been all over the aeroelectric website and downloaded just about
everything.
-------Original Message-------
From:
murphy-rebel@dcsol.com
Date: Monday, December 08, 2003 6:43:11 AM
To:
murphy-rebel@dcsol.com
Subject: Re: SR electrical with V8
Mike
I've been subscribed to Bob Knuckoll's aeroelectric list for a few years
and I must admit that he has largely converted me to his thinking with
precise analysis and detailed data. That is really the place to hash out
your thoughts. I'd suggest you ponder the well thought out published
diagrams in his book and on his web site.
Post Message:
aeroelectric-list@matronics.com
UN/SUBSCRIBE:
http://www.matronics.com/subscription
List FAQ:
http://www.matronics.com/FAQ/AeroElectric-List.htm
Search Engine:
http://www.matronics.com/search
7-Day Browse:
http://www.matronics.com/browse/aeroelectric-list
Browse Digests:
http://www.matronics.com/digest/aeroelectric-list
My own wiring is still in my head but I have given it some thought.
The achievable goal is that no single failure should cause anything more
than a minor annoyance. As a preliminary starting point, your diagram is
reminiscent of old certified thinking. My immediate thoughts are:
What is the box labelled 'Bat Iso'? Fuses or an ANL might be a good idea
between the batteries but don't think you want anything in the way of
diodes there.
If your intent is that either battery can power your engine till you run
out of gas then the batteries must be replaced often to insure
sufficient reserve capacity. Weight wise, a small second alternator
becomes an interesting alternative. In fact though one RG battery and
one alternator gives you two sources of power. An RG battery is by far
the most reliable item in the electric system but capacity declines with
age of course. Your diagram implies two large batteries as the second
one does not appear dedicated to keeping the engine alive. With two
large batteries some guys use a crossfeed contactor so both can power
the starter (It looks like your system might be able to do that as well
depending on what your Bat Sel box is). With one alternator on an SR,
I'd lean in that direction with possibly two PC680 batteries and
rotating them with one new one every year to guarantee reserve capacity.
A crossfeed switch or relay might make more sense than your Bat Sel switch.
It is extremely important to incorporate a low voltage warning device as
the alternator lights are not reliable.
Some guys run both ignitions simultaneously for takeoff and landing.
However in any case I'd suggest two switches instead of one for
selecting. Why go to the trouble of dual ignition but wire them through
one switch such that one switch failure can kill both ignitions? And why
feed both from the same source of power? If you are going to carry two
batteries, use them as independant engine power sources. Wire at least
one ignition and fuel pump directly to a battery.
I am convinced that there is no technical need for an avionics master
switch. I'd also suggest that a split master is pointless as you'll want
a fuse or ANL current limiter between the battery and alternator anyway.
Ideally you'd also have an overvoltage device to kill the alternator.
All the damage will usually be done before you can manually turn off a
runaway alternator.
There are some practical reasons to consider using a fuse block for the
bus rather than c/b's. Compared to one wire into a fuse block, C/B's
are more hassle to wire and often take up significant panel space. With
a well though out system you won't have any need to reset circuit
breakers in flight. Mind you I picked up switch breakers cheaper than
switches would have cost so I'm not planning fuses either ;)
Ken
Mike Kimball wrote:
Hi everyone,
I just uploaded a drawing of the complete electrical system for my V8
powered SR to the SR-Systems folder. I sure would love to have some of you
people that know what you're doing look it over and tell me all the stuff
that's wrong. It includes the dual electronic ignition setup I am using.
Thanks in advance.
Mike Kimball
SR #044
*-------------------------------------------------------------------------*
To unsubscribe from this list go to:
https://www.dcsol.com/public/code/html-subscribe.wcx
Archives located at
https://rebel:builder@www.dcsol.com/default.htm
To contact the list admin, e-mail
mike.davis@dcsol.com
*-------------------------------------------------------------------------*
-----------------------------------------------------------------
List archives located at:
https://mail.dcsol.com/login
username "rebel" password "builder"
Unsubscribe:
rebel-builders-unsubscribe@dcsol.com
List administrator:
mike.davis@dcsol.com
-----------------------------------------------------------------